Masters Dissertation – SEARCWL https://searcwl.ac.zw Mon, 16 Dec 2024 11:11:28 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.1 ACCESS BY A GIRL CHILD WITH PROFOUND VISUAL CHALLENGES TO PRIMARY EDUCATION IN ZIMBABWE https://searcwl.ac.zw/?dlp_document=access-by-a-girl-child-with-profound-visual-challenges-to-primary-education-in-zimbabwe Mon, 16 Dec 2024 11:07:42 +0000 https://searcwl.ac.zw/?post_type=dlp_document&p=5729 A Dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for a Masters in Women’s Law, Southern and Eastern African Regional Centre for Women’s Law, University of Zimbabwe 2010

]]>
Legal assistance for indigent women A critical analysis of services provided by Zimbabwe Women lawyers association in Bulawayo https://searcwl.ac.zw/?dlp_document=legal-assistance-for-indigent-women-a-critical-analysis-of-services-provided-by-zimbabwe-women-lawyers-association-in-bulawayo Thu, 28 Sep 2023 09:48:01 +0000 https://searcwl.ac.zw/?post_type=dlp_document&p=5435 ZIMBABWE’S FOREST LAWS, POLICIES AND PRACTICES AND IMPLICATIONS FOR ACCESS, CONTROL AND OWNERSHIP OF FOREST RESOURCES BY RURAL WOMEN https://searcwl.ac.zw/?dlp_document=zimbabwes-forest-laws-policies-and-practices-and-implications-for-access-control-and-ownership-of-forest-resources-by-rural-women Thu, 28 Sep 2023 09:46:11 +0000 https://searcwl.ac.zw/?post_type=dlp_document&p=5408 This dissertation exposes the legal and other obstacles which prevent rural women, Zimbabwe’s traditional environmental stewards, from fully realizing their human right (HR) both to sustain their families from forest produce and help to preserve the country’s forests. The researcher’s deft use of several gender-focused methodologies and complementary data collection methods combine to present clear evidence of the urgent issues at stake. The study’s overall guiding methodology of the Grounded/Women’s Law Approach maintains its focus on the affected women, whose experiences are revealed as ‘lived realities’ within a rich multilayered private and public context, the legal implications of which help to highlight their problems and suggest possible solutions. The latter are finally presented as valuable

 

legislative and other reforms and recommendations which are laudably motivated by the desire to ensure that Zimbabwe complies with its local, regional and international HR obligations.

]]>
WOMEN’S VIOLENT CRIME AGAINST ABUSIVE PARTNERS IN ZAMBIA: A CRITIQUE OF THE DEFENCE OF ‘PROVOCATION’ https://searcwl.ac.zw/?dlp_document=womens-violent-crime-against-abusive-partners-in-zambia-a-critique-of-the-defence-of-provocation Thu, 28 Sep 2023 09:45:15 +0000 https://searcwl.ac.zw/?post_type=dlp_document&p=5407 The objectives of this study, conducted by a Zambian law enforcement officer, were to: (i) establish how women exposed to long-term domestic violence (DV) develop the

 

baula’ reaction (i.e., slow anger reaction) resulting in their killing their abusive partners; (ii) investigate whether the defence of provocation discriminates against female offenders; (iii) interrogate whether judges have developed the defence of provocation in a gender-sensitive manner; and (iv) recommend the broadening of the defence of provocation in the Penal Code by catering for acts not done ‘in the heat of the moment’ (or as a result of the ‘baula’ reaction). In order for an accused person to plead the defence of provocation successfully in terms of sections 205 and 206 of the Penal Code, the killing must have been committed ‘in the heat of the moment,’ which, unfortunately, does not fit into the lived realities of abused woman as revealed by the findings of this study. The research, which focused on the lived realities of 11 respondent women convicted of spousal homicide, was scientifically conducted within a strong gender-sensitive theoretical and methodological framework, in particular, the Women’s Law Approach which embraced, among others, the Grounded Theory and Human Rights Approaches. Relevant data for the study included extensive desk research of the law, court case transcripts, literature, in-depth interviews and/or focus group discussions with the respondent women and members of the legal profession, judiciary, police force, church, teaching profession and the NGO community as well as researchers, cultural gate keepers and a psychologist. The findings of the study were that: (i) society does not expect a woman to react in a violent way towards her abusive partner due to the deep-rooted cultural belief that a man has absolute control over his wife; (ii) judges interpret provocative acts using double standards based on gender ideologies; (iii) men (as opposed to women) are usually the instigators of intimate partner violence; (iv) the ‘baula’(or slow anger) reaction causes women to kill their abusive partners at a time when they are not provoked; and (v) Section 205 of the Penal Code is too narrow and needs to be amended to include responses to provocative acts not done ‘in the heat of the moment.’ The study concluded that, generally, abused women have difficulties in successfully pleading the defence of provocation as they do not normally react ‘in the heat of the moment’. In accordance with Zambia’s regional and international Human Rights commitments, the study finally formulated an action plan: (i) on the need to amend by widening the provisions of sections 205 and 206 of the Penal Code; (ii) by using appropriate stakeholders to lobby for the amendment. (iii) After the amendment of the defence, workshops should be held for judges and magistrates to encourage them to take judicial notice of the fact that women are socialised against reacting to their abusive partners and that, when they eventually ‘snap’, they do not do so ‘in the heat of the moment’ but rather as a result of the ‘baula’ (slow anger) reaction; and, (iv) the Anti-Gender Based Violence Act of 2011 should be included in the police training curriculum to help officers effectively reduce DV and, ultimately, spousal homicides.

]]>
WOMEN’S BODIES AS TOOLS OF WAR AND TERROR DURING THE POST ELECTION VIOLENCE (PEV) IN KENYA (December 2007- 2008) AND THE IMPLICATIONS FOR JUSTICE (Experiences of the Internally Displaced Women at Nakuru/Naivasha area) https://searcwl.ac.zw/?dlp_document=womens-bodies-as-tools-of-war-and-terror-during-the-post-election-violence-pev-in-kenya-december-2007-2008-and-the-implications-for-justice-experiences-of-the-internally-displaced-women Thu, 28 Sep 2023 09:44:05 +0000 https://searcwl.ac.zw/?post_type=dlp_document&p=5406 Two years after the horror of Kenya’s inter-tribal post election violence (PEV), the writer of this dissertation [a member of the Federation of Women Lawyers of Kenya (FIDA K)], courageously investigates why justice still eludes the female victims (ranging from

 

teenagers to grandmothers) of the widespread politically-motivated serial rapes (especially gang rapes) instigated by the country’s two major warring political parties. Still traumatised by and ashamed to speak about their experiences of these gender-specific crimes against humanity (a taboo subject grossly underreported in the public and private, local and international domains), these brutalised women silently suffer living as Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) herded into impoverished camps around the country which lack any/sufficient shelter, water, food or medical attention. At worst, these women have been infected with HIV/AIDS and, shorn of all their possessions, families and jobs, are forced to raise, single-handedly and without any state help, the children of the savage rapes whom the state (having denied them abortions) has forced them to bear. Guided overall by the Women’s Law Approach, the writer skilfully combines several methodologies, including the Grounded and Human Rights Approaches, to conduct her research scientifically, collecting and analysing the relevant law and literature on the subject, as well as valuable evidence from a large number of women victims, some young male perpetrators of the violence, policemen, camp and NGO officials. She presents her findings through the ‘lived realities’ or eyes of these tragic victims and within the context of the multiple breaches of their human rights caused during and after the PEV which HRs are protected by various HR instruments binding on Kenya. These violations include the State’s violation of its duty during the PEV to protect the women from physical attacks against their person, families and property (members of its police force often perpetrated or condoned the violence) and its violation in the IDP camps of their rights to reproductive and general health, water, food, shelter and resettlement. Despite clear evidence of these breaches they remain unredressed, essentially because the PEV was largely sanctioned by men who were and still are competing for state power over which they wield control. Therefore, despite growing local and international pressure, they lack the political will to hold themselves and their stooges publicly accountable for atrocities caused by their abuses of power. Finally, the writer suggests several Constitutional, legal and social reforms which should help to realise some measure of justice for these all-but-forgotten women who feel justifiably betrayed by both the Kenyan State and an apparently well-meaning, but currently underperforming, local and international HR community.

]]>
WOMEN’S PARTICIPATION IN WATER GOVERNANCE STRUCTURES OF DIFFERENT WATER PROVIDERS. A CASE STUDY OF COMMUNITY WATER PROJECTS AND WATER KIOSKS IN NAKURU, KENYA https://searcwl.ac.zw/?dlp_document=womens-participation-in-water-governance-structures-of-different-water-providers-a-case-study-of-community-water-projects-and-water-kiosks-in-nakuru-kenya Thu, 28 Sep 2023 09:42:02 +0000 https://searcwl.ac.zw/?post_type=dlp_document&p=5405 Unable to satisfy the nation’s need for water, the Kenyan Government has, in the case of Nakuru, the country’s fourth largest city, embarked on two water privatisation projects with local profit-making companies, one to service its urban and the other its rural community. This dissertation analyses the extent to which both these communities dismally fail to access sufficient water for their daily needs, primarily as a result of their women being excluded from the structures which establish and manage the allocation and delivery of their community water. Consequently, the entire health and integrity of the Nakuru community has been seriously compromised and the lives of its marginalised women severely disrupted since, as the communities prime carers and, hence, prime water users, they spend their precious hours queuing or searching for water. The privatised water scheme either fails to deliver water efficiently or at a rate beyond the means of the average resident. Guided overall by the Women’s Law Approach, the researcher effectively combines several other methodologies, especially Grounded and Human Rights based Theories, to research this topic which he conducts by implementing several complementary data collection methods including in-depth interviews, focus discussion groups (of a selection of affected women as well as relevant government and community

 

representatives) and extensive research into the relevant laws and literature in the area. He discovers that, although the Kenyan government has established a commendable policy and legal framework which protects the right of women to access water, it has failed to make this right a reality for various reasons, including its failure to address the negative aspects of poverty, illiteracy, culture, and, especially, gender discrimination. For example, the Government fails to hold private water companies to account for failing to ensure that the minimum legal number of women from the local community are elected on to its

 

critical management structures. Hence, in order to improve this situation, the Kenyan Government is encouraged to make the establishment and management of any water development project more sensitive to and pro-active in favour of supplying the water needs of its communities’ women. He also suggests that, amongst other things, men and women should participate equally in the establishment and management of any water project. It should also follow the lead of South Africa whose Constitutional Court recognises that the Government should provide a minimum amount of water to its poorest and most vulnerable citizens, especially its women, free of charge.

]]>
WOMEN’ ENTREPRENEURSHIP DEVELOPMENT: A CASE STUDY OF MODELS’ ASSESSMENT IN FACILITATING WOMEN TO GENERATE SOCIAL-FINANCIAL CAPITAL IN MWANZA CITY, TANZANIA https://searcwl.ac.zw/?dlp_document=women-entrepreneurship-development-a-case-study-of-models-assessment-in-facilitating-women-to-generate-social-financial-capital-in-mwanza-city-tanzania Thu, 28 Sep 2023 09:41:16 +0000 https://searcwl.ac.zw/?post_type=dlp_document&p=5403 Sustained and meaningful economic development remains beyond the reach of the majority of Tanzania’s poorer female citizens, especially those in the informal sector, because they lack collateral (i.e., ownership of land) to secure loans from formal financial institutions for their income-generating projects. This dissertation compares and contrasts 3 micro-financing models (two implemented by the Government and one by an international donor organisation) which are formed around small (5) to medium (30) sized social groups which generate what the writer calls “social-financial capital”. The two government models [i.e., the Women’s Development Fund (WDF) and the Tanzania Social Action Fund (TASAF)] operate along typically traditional lines of training, equipping and granting soft and low interest bearing loans to groups of women to start up or continue running their own businesses. Care International’s Village Savings and Loans Associations (VSLs) function more like an easy-to-understand insurance scheme or people’s bank whose self-selected shareholders/owners/officers comprise both men and women who save by buying shares in the scheme on a regular basis and are free to use the loans they grant themselves or cyclical profits they regularly distribute between among themselves in any way they wish. In order to reveal the gender dynamics at play within and around the operations of these semi-formal groups, the writer conducts her research of them using several gender-sensitive methodologies guided overall by the unique Women’s Law Approach. Using complementary forms of data collection methods, she gathers and analyses a vast array of evidence both documentary (i.e., relevant laws and literature) and verbal (from interviews and discussions with her respondents and key government and NGO informants) which she presents from the perspective or ‘lived realities’ of her respondents, female beneficiaries of the 3 models operating in Mwanza City on the southern shores of Lake Victoria. She finds, inter alia, that although VSLs are ideal for generating relatively small amounts sufficient to sustain (as opposed to start a business), their lack of gender sensitivity make them less attractive to women than the government models which address not only their financial but also their educational, social and cultural needs upon which their lives and, hence, businesses are so dependent. Finally, based on her findings, the writer makes suggestions to improve the models in order to encourage the government and Care International to fulfil their roles in helping to realise the economic rights of these women in terms of relevant Regional and International Human Rights Instruments which the government seeks to uphold.

]]>
PARTICIPATION OF RURAL WOMEN IN LOCAL GOVERNANCE IN MUREWA DISTRICT, ZIMBABWE: WOMEN WALKING POLITICAL PATHS! https://searcwl.ac.zw/?dlp_document=the-writer-of-this-dissertation-a-local-ngo-officer-uses-her-inside-knowledge-of-the-murewa-rural-district-council-mrdc-to-explore-through-the-increased-participation-of-women-c Thu, 28 Sep 2023 09:39:12 +0000 https://searcwl.ac.zw/?post_type=dlp_document&p=5402 The writer of this dissertation, a local NGO officer, uses her inside knowledge of the Murewa Rural District Council (“MRDC”) to explore, through the increased participation of women councillors, the potential for their own personal development and that of the district, in general. She collects and analyses a wide range of data utilising several women-centred methodologies (including the Women’s Law and Grounded Theory Approaches) in order to reveal the ‘lived realities’ of several women councillors which, in turn, points to the legal, social, economic and other contexts between which they juggle their private and public lives. In order for Zimbabwe to comply with its international human rights obligations to improve women’s political rights, she suggests, inter alia, the limited use of quota systems and gender-sensitive political education programmes.

]]>
The factors influencing the decisions of women refugees to leave camps or settlements and settle in Kampala City https://searcwl.ac.zw/?dlp_document=the-factors-influencing-the-decisions-of-women-refugees-to-leave-camps-or-settlements-and-settle-in-kampala-city-2 Thu, 28 Sep 2023 09:37:59 +0000 https://searcwl.ac.zw/?post_type=dlp_document&p=5401 The Zambian women parliamentarians caucus: Making inroads into the legislative process https://searcwl.ac.zw/?dlp_document=the-zambian-women-parliamentarians-caucus-making-inroads-into-the-legislative-process Thu, 28 Sep 2023 09:29:04 +0000 https://searcwl.ac.zw/?post_type=dlp_document&p=5399